Certain actors leave behind their mark on character roles, especially if they have been playing it for a while. This is particularly true for actors playing popular heroes in the superhero genre, which is why fans would always associate Robert Downey Jr. with Iron Man no matter what mantel he picks up.
While DC fans could argue for eons about who was the best Superman, one fan demolished all competition. A fanart showcased four iconic renditions of the popular superhero, as they watched over the planet together. The sweet memorabilia of past and future Supermen is a testament to the character’s popularity and fan devotion.
Not the best out of the bunch but the bunch itself
Henry Cavill‘s Man of Steel successfully launched the actor in the role of Superman. The dark and gritty tale intrigued the viewers who were desperately waiting for the promised sequel which was never delivered.
Now with James Gunn taking over the mantle and deciding to reboot the entire storyline, times have changed. David Corenswet was signed as the last son of Krypton for the upcoming 2025’s Superman.
Fan wars, especially over their favorite portrayals, are a common feature of any fandom let alone the massive superhero genre. However, one fan decided to single-handedly remove all debate by posting a heartwarming fanart that featured four actors who played the iconic superhero.
‘SUPERMEN’ by @AaronBaileyArt pic.twitter.com/8nLIf5E3gv
— DC Film News (@DCFilmNews) October 18, 2024
Looks cool
— Venom🜃🔩 (@Venom01985379) October 18, 2024
It would make andy muschietti proud
— ؘ (@domi__ti) October 18, 2024
— MARVEL/DC: NEWS📰🚨 (@ImpactCom1) October 18, 2024
The image included the legendary Christopher Reeve, Cavill, Tyler Hoechlin, and the newly joined Corenswet in their costumes. Together, the heroic bunch looked as if overseeing the planet, making many fans emotional.
A comment mentioned The Flash director Andy Muschietti and how he would be ‘proud’ of the art. Previously, the filmmaker’s name was linked with the potential sequel for Cavill’s 2013 film, according to Comic Book News.
Fan reaction and the debate for the best continues
News of the new casting provoked mixed reactions from fans, most saddened by the end of the Argylle actor’s reign. The upcoming star also spoke to Entertainment Weekly about his aspirations for the role.
 I love the Henry Cavill dark and gritty take, but I would love to see the next one be very bright and optimistic.
On a separate Redditt chain fans discussed the portrayal of Hoechlin in Superman & Lois, calling it the best adaptation. Many comments praised the actor and his authentic performance in the show.
Tyler Hoechlin is the best adaptation of Superman, we just need to admit it
byu/ogpakisaurus insuperman
Comment
byu/ogpakisaurus from discussion
insuperman
Comment
byu/ogpakisaurus from discussion
insuperman
Comment
byu/ogpakisaurus from discussion
insuperman
Comment
byu/ogpakisaurus from discussion
insuperman
Comment
byu/ogpakisaurus from discussion
insuperman
On the other hand, most classic movie-goers would recall seeing Reeves portray the iconic DC hero. He debuted in the role through Richard Donner’s seminal 1978 classic and later three more sequels.
The Black Fox actor had to accomplish the hard task of overcoming George Reeves‘ shadow, who popularized the superhero via Adventures of Superman in the 1950s. All four actors, along with others aptly portrayed the character according to their requirements and perspectives.
It is up to the Twisters actor to step into the big shoes and establish his legacy. Gunn revealed that they had wrapped the shooting for the film and it is expected to release on 11 July 2025.
Superman: The Movie is currently available to watch on Prime Video.
Man of Steel is currently available to watch on Max.
Superman & Lois is currently available to watch on Max.
